Dear Boy Who I Think I Could Never Have A Chance With But Everyone Else Thought You Like/Liked Me But I Have Ignored It For Like 5 Years And Now Have A Long-Term Boyfriend,
I've had it bad for you for so long now. The "what-ifs" haunt me. Almost constantly. You're the boy every parent wants her daughter to date (and then marry). I've always told myself that I wasn't good enough for you. You're the pastor's son. But even when I turned into a preacher's daughter, I still thought I didn't have what you need. So I went through a ton of heartbreak, trying to find someone else. And now I've been with my boyfriend for over a year and a half. And I love him, so, so much. And I see a future with him, and we're working towards that. But sometimes I wonder, while I'm crying because my boyfriend is unsupportive, or when I walk into church on Sunday with him after we've had some stupid arguement (like we do most Sundays), if I should've given you and me a chance anyway. If I'm making a mistake in planning a future with my boyfriend instead of you.
I know I'm only human, and I'm sure a lot of people have felt this way towards someone. But I still feel bad every time my mind starts to wonder to those annoying "what-ifs" that most of the time I can ignore. But now this thing has happened in my family, something that you could most likely help me through due to it's close-to-home nature... While my boyfriend isn't very tactful and quite insensitive about the whole thing. And when I saw you today, the emotions came in waves.
I just wanted to write you this letter. To tell you that I care for you. And always have. And that I'm sorry if there was ever a time where you felt the same and I ignored you. It was never you, it's always been me--my insecurities and fears--that have caused us to never be together. But I have this boy who I love in my life now, and unless something happened (which I can't even imagine), you and I will never have that chance.
With [much] love,
Me.